I just got done reading the comments posted on my Harry Potter reviews.
Ouch.
To start with, I have no idea why there was so much criticism of things I never actually said. It's like it was presumed there was some hidden, hostile meaning in the faults I found. So, I'm going to set the record straight.
I do not hate the Potter movies. I'm re-watching the last one tonight as a matter of fact. Am I a fan? No. That's just my own personal taste. Like I said, I find magic in any media to be iffy simply because if you have such a gift, why is used only in some circumstances but then conveniently not used in others? I was merely commenting how how often Harry and/or his friends could have gotten themselves out of tough situations if they had simply done what they had done before when they did get out of tight spots.
I don't know where all the criticism came from, but since I never said what I got pasted for, it kinda stang a little bit. I never said the Potter books or movies were evil nor did I watch the movies wanting to hate them or find fault in them. They seemed interesting enough and I watched them. Sure the movie didn't explain things very well (I still wonder what became of certain characters), but they weren't awful. And I don't have impossible standards as far as film is concerned. Sure, I am a bit critical because I wanted (and kinda still do) to be a film critic. That means turning a movie inside-out. Force of habit. The faults I found in the Potter movies didn't not ruin the whole experience. True, like other film, I don't get all the hype. I mean the Potter films were pretty good, but I didn't find them as good as "Lord of the Rings" or others There were plenty of positive elements in the movies that people find touching and I won't mess with that. I found some great moments in there as well.
I didn't say these movies should be condemned to hell. I'm not ignorantly reviewing something I have absolutely no knowledge of. Sure I'm no expert, but it's not like all experts on Harry Potter are destined to be die-hard fans. As I said before, I'm a critical person, but just because a film has a flaw doesn't mean I hate it. Every film has flaws. And pointing them out doesn't mean I think the film sucks.
I guess I can understand why you wouldn't be such a fan because you didn't grow up reading the books and seeing the movies the weekend they premiered.
ReplyDeleteI'd like to apologize for the comments i wrote on the actual review, I'm sorry. you've been nice enough to not bash on blogs of mine that you've commented on so I should've been a little more considerate.
You're not insinuating that there are actual flaws in the Harry Potter movies are you!?! (what's the symbol to convey irony?)
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI looked it up. The symbol for irony is simply "⸮"
ReplyDelete